Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha The Movie 1st Review

(I found myself in the mood to write reviews of my favorite anime in the style of Roger Ebert’s “Great Movies” articles, and having just rewatched the Nanoha movie, this happened.)

Nanoha The Movie 1st is sold on one fantastic battle scene and one fantastic dialog scene that wouldn’t be possible without the rest of the movie, even though they overshadow it in such a way that they alone deserve rewatching again and again.

Nanoha’s problems as a film mostly come from the problems it had as a TV series and the problems of its production.

In the latter case, Nanoha suffers the general weakness of being produced by Seven Arcs, a mediocre studio that, when given the kind of budget to make this film, succeeded only in not fucking it up, without doing much to elevate it to the level that it could’ve reached. There are no ugly images in the film, yet the fights aren’t cool—effort was put into enhancing formerly ugly, uncool fights into uncool fights that look just fine. This can be attributed to the studio’s never having worked on a movie before, nor anything above mediocre, low-budget, late-night TV shows.

The problems that the TV series had were generally being awful and poorly planned. Nanoha season 1 begins as a generic mahou shoujo item-collecting story, then evolves into a story about a tragic girl seeking redemption through friendship. The resulting emotional plot about Nanoha and Fate’s friendship is the money of the show, but the presentation is awful. The story is stupid, not well thought-out, and entirely forgettable.

Nanoha The Movie 1st doesn’t change any of this. It removes a lot of the useless meandering of the series, streamlining the story into a more cohesive whole, but it doesn’t change the fact that the story is stupid to begin with. What we get is just a better-looking, less lame retelling.

I can look past this. The stupidity of the plot isn’t important. It only becomes a problem when it stands in the way of scene progression and the better parts of the movie. Towards the end, when Precia explains her past and motives, she repeats herself incessantly. I can summarize twenty minutes of dialog as follows:

Precia was a scientist that didn’t spend much time with her daughter. Her daughter died in an accident, so Precia cloned her. However, the clone wasn’t the same as the original, so Precia treated her like shit and longed for her real daughter to be reborn.

—These few plot points are repeated again and again, as if the movie isn’t sure we understand why the characters act the way they do, so it must more throughly restate exactly what it just said.

At this point, the movie wouldn’t be worth watching without its best scenes. Between the lame fights and sometimes annoying dialog, I wouldn’t want to go through the whole thing again. However, if I have to watch the whole movie while introducing it to a new viewer, I can watch all of it for the payoff of the two best scenes.

First is the final battle between Nanoha and Fate, which Nanoha prefaces by calling it their “first and last real fight.” The setup of this fight is great because of Nanoha’s total confidence in her victory and the friendship she will share with Fate thereafter. We learn that the Bureau intends to use the fight to their advantage no matter which of the girls wins, but Nanoha doesn’t know this. Nanoha’s victory would be imminent with or without their help because she hasn’t a doubt in her mind about how much ass she’s going to kick. She and Raising Heart have an “ace in the hole” that will ensure victory.

The fight is set up to resemble an aerial dogfight, with the girls’ flight patterns moving in deliberate jet paths, and cuts of their pink and yellow trails left like exhaust. There are even scenes of the girls firing at one-another wherein their bullets appear to curve through the air. Like the rest of the film, the battle is full of anime conceits and the general lack of measurable attack effectiveness that makes so many anime battles fail, but there’s enough intensity to the animation and emotions of the characters that the battle remains entertaining.

At the end of the fight, Nanoha cashes in on her confidence. Fate, tired out, launches everything she has at Nanoha, thinking that Nanoha must be just as tired. Nanoha is barely hurt, and retaliates with her newly devised ultimate attack (a riff on the Spirit Bomb technique from Dragon Ball Z), which completely obliterates Fate, showing that Nanoha was on an entirely different level all along.

art by fukudori

The other brilliant scene is the ending, when Nanoha and Fate finally get to meet properly, knowing it’ll be more than six months before they get to see one-another again. It’s a big, gay, emotional dialog exchange—an “I love you, man,” moment taken to its farthest extremes, until it’s actually a thinly veiled lesbian confession. (Supposedly, several people who worked on the show consider it canon that this scene was exactly that, and that Nanoha and Fate are, without question, a couple.)

The scene is sold by its sheer honesty and straightforward lack of embarrassment. Fate’s life will never be the same—Nanoha has changed her entire world and become its most important inhabitant. Nanoha has found a best friend for life. They spill their guts and embrace one-another, trade hair ties as mementos, and tearfully depart. It’s the gushiest, most fulfilling friendship moment in anime.

Ultimately, though, Nanoha The Movie 1st is worth watching because Nanoha A’s comes after it and cashes in on the characters, the themes, and, more than anything, the development of Nanoha and Fate’s relationship. Nanoha A’s wouldn’t be as utterly amazing as it is without the origin story of Nanoha and Fate’s relationship, and retroactively, Nanoha and Fate’s story means even more when we know where it’ll take them, both in A’s and in Strikers. The existence of those future stories is what lifts Nanoha The Movie 1st from a decent movie with great scenes to a worthwhile movie with a fantastic ending.

While it would be understandable for someone that doesn’t like the movie to end their involvement with the series there, it would be seriously remiss for anyone that enjoys the movie not to cash in on that enjoyment with the superb sequels. Thankfully, Nanoha A’s will be receiving its own film adaption in the near future.

14 thoughts on “Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha The Movie 1st Review

  1. >While it would be understandable for someone that doesn’t like the movie to end their involvement with the series there, it would be seriously remiss for anyone that enjoys the movie not to cash in on that enjoyment with the superb sequels.
    Say, that reminds me of a certain someone!
    But yeah, I totally agree with what you’re saying here. The show itself was compressed with a lot of junk removed, but then they had to spend a full half hour or so pandering on Precia, which felt draggy and pointless at best. Personally though, the fight scenes weren’t really uncool – I thought they were pretty good. Watching them on a pretty TV and surround sound helps too ;3
    The main point of watching the movie though, is that a) it’s a pretty good retelling of the entire first season, which is all right for the fans, and b) that it readies you for the sheer awesomeness that is A’s. Seeing as a Nanoha movie’s been announced for next year, I certainly hope that it’s like a 3-hour long battlefest from A’s. The final fight against the corrupted Reinforce program, especially, with the entire cast all getting together, coordinating attacks… oh man, just thinking about it gets me burning.

    • The fights in the movie make good sound and light shows because of the great music and sound effects, helped by the home theater we watched it on. However, the fights do everything I find wrong with anime fights. Poor sense of distance and space at all times, a camera that doesn’t follow attacks as they happen: take, for instance, the many times it would show a girl launching a bullet, and then cut to the enemy being hit by the bullet. In a good fight, we would either see that all in one frame, or the camera would follow the bullet. It increases the sense of impact and confirmation of distance. Not to mention the amount of damage done by attacks is entirely arbitrary. Fights basically last until the next set piece comes along to end them. The blob monsters and shit were lame opponents, too. And they kept needlessly cutting to shots of Bardiche and Raising Heart calling out the attacks, diverting from the action.

      I think the worst part for me is in the scene where Nanoha and Fate are flying down to get their hands on the jewel shard thing, and even though it looked like they were each twenty feet away in one shot, we see various cuts of them flying, the distance growing and shortening to make it ambiguous who might reach the shard first.

      For me, a fight either has to be sold on the strength of great fight direction, or on the sheer level of badass shit going on. The penultimate NanoFate battle isn’t that strongly directed, but so much cool shit happens that it remains totally memorable. The other fights in the movie are just forgettable at best.

      The first time I watched the movie I was so blown away by the good stuff that I largely forgot about the bad, so this time, the bad parts really stood out lol. Still a good damn movie after all, though.

  2. In my own review I praised the larger focus on Precia, but I would agree that the Precia thing kinda dragged on like forever. I may have overlooked that because it involved Fate/Alicia, but the movie had a tendency to force you to feel for the antagonist more than the usual. Maybe a repeat viewing like yours would make me see those kinds of downs, although I would only find it to be nitpicks towards an overall good movie.

    I’m not sure I share your enthusiasm towards A’s though, mostly because I totally forgot what happened (oh my amnesia). The first Nanoha’s plot was more memorable, and it made this first movie stick out to me because of that nostalgia. I guess I’ll be viewing A’s movie next year with a blank slate except for maybe the characters. BTW, next year’s too long. Dang.

  3. If I ever write any reviews, I would write something like this one. For many of the reasons you say here, but most importantly the underwhelming fights (and wtf fugly ass monsters) put me off.

    Kind of feels weird to type a comment while you’re right behind me.

  4. By the time I finished reading the fourth paragraph, I would’ve stopped reading and closed the tab for the site, because this post pretty much justified what people people need to know about Nanoha before they decide to take on the franchise. You could say I have the same sentiment as ghostlightning’s (HeartCatch Precure is probably more interesting and watchable than Nanoha in general), but I digress.

    If anything, Nanoha lacked almost everything that needs to be stressed, to the point where they had to make a movie to make it acceptable. And that’s amidst all the viral and officially supported speculations circulating in the Nanoha fandom (such as “You Gonna Be Befriended”, “The Sadistic White Devil”, etc.)

  5. When I first watched the movie, the lack of a proper climax hit me hard. Slogging through the second half of the movie was just a damn chore, since it dragged on with tons of melodrama. The aerial battles were great, but I’ve always had an issue with Seven Arcs’ character designs.

    I’m not a Fate fan, so the film’s attention to Precia was nigh-unbearable. I felt that the movie tried too hard to push Precia as this sympathetic character, but it didn’t work. Precia just sucks, period. The Fate torture bits are… yeah.

  6. Y’know this review doesn’t coincide very well with your previous remarks about the movie. You even remarked that it was an A+ and one of your favorite watches ever in a blog post not too long ago.

    • I’ve never claimed to be consistent. Anyway, I love the movie, and this is not a negative review. I was, however, a bit disappointed with my rewatch of the movie and will be removing it from my favorites list—not that I don’t still love it.

  7. Pingback: Digibro | The Digi Bump

  8. Pingback: + Analysis | The Digi Bump

  9. Pingback: Anime/Manga Analysis | The Digi Bump

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s