I Have No Favorite Anime

Oh shoot, I’m posting in March. Looks like my slot in the anime blogger tourney is set in stone now.

If you read my twitter, then you know that I’ve spent the past month or so neck-deep in My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic fandom. I haven’t felt so strongly about a show in years, possibly something like ten years, reaching back into my original Pokemon fandom. Is it ironic for a die-hard anime fan to find his true love in an American/Canadian cartoon? Maybe, but more importantly, it raises a question which no one has asked, yet I feel that I’ve been avoiding (or at least waiting till I was comfortable enough to answer). Do I like My Little Pony more than anime?

This brings me to a conundrum that I’ve faced for quite some time, and which has caused me to completely stop writing favorites lists altogether (!!!) for something like half a year. I have no favorite anime.

There just isn’t one anime which I feel so strongly connected to that it could be called my favorite show, above all others. Last year, when ghostlightning made his most awesome favorites list, he had just rewatched Revolutionary Girl Utena and found that he loved it in a huge way—but there was no question that Super Dimensional Fortress Macross was still his number one favorite anime, because his connection to that show simply outdoes what Utena might even be capable of.

I probably don’t care about any one show as much as ghostlightning cares about either of those. The last time I strongly felt that I had a favorite anime was when I wrote about Kara no Kyoukai back in 2010. Back then I had a strong grasp of what I thought made me care about a show. I no longer do. My last favorites list (not currently visible) had K-On!! in the #1 slot, and I said right on the list itself that I didn’t really feel that K-On!! was supposed to be my favorite anime, it was just the one that I cared about most at the time.

I feel there’s no anime which I’ve already seen that has the power to be my favorite anime. If it did, it already would be. Instead of caring about them more, I’ve only cared less about most of my “favorites” over time. At the end of last year, I felt that Steins;Gate and Madoka were my favorite shows of the year and had a strong chance of being on my “favorites list” – but I didn’t include them, nor alter my list in any way, because the whole concept felt weightless. Were I to include them, would I rank them? How arbitrary would it feel? My list always feels arbitrary, like its last member could easily be substituted for something else, or like there isn’t really a gap in how much I care for number five against number one. Then why have a list? Forget it. I liked Madoka and Steins;Gate most of 2011 anime. It doesn’t matter anymore. Those are just some shows I like, so I’ll remember them, and the memory can speak for itself.

There’s no question that My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic is my favorite show right now. I haven’t stopped being constantly entrenched in it. I’ve seen some episodes upwards of four times in the past month, be it from showing a bunch to other people or watching it on TV or just rewatching episodes on my own. It’s a show where I know a considerable amount of dialog, and can sing a great deal of the fanmade songs already. Not to mention I’ve already made some. This show has mobilized me like nothing else, and I can’t remember being into fandom this hard since my last two-week nico nico douga binge. And I’ve been binging MLP for at least three weeks and counting.

Do I like MLP more than anime? No, that’s insane. Anime is an entire medium. But I do like it more than any individual anime that I’ve seen.

11 thoughts on “I Have No Favorite Anime

  1. See, I enjoy the actual fandom surrounding the show more than I do the show ITSELF. The remixes, the dubs, the flash animations, the comic strips, the MOUNTAINS of fanfic (hell, even the pornogrpahy for God’s sake…): it’s staggering.

    There’s this enormous subculture that’s grown up around this cartoon intended for young girls, and I find the fan produced content voluminous enough in some cases to actually outshine the actual progenitor. Not that the show itself isn’t good, but I don’t think the material necessarily merits this kind of attention.

    • Mm… I love all the fanwork too, but it all just serves to make the core series even better and more interesting. For instance, I didn’t care for Trixie’s episode, but the fan works about her have created a personal canon for me that’s made her one of my favorite characters in the series. And then there’s stuff like this dude’s in-depth character analysis that just goes to make the show more interesting and deep http://nimaru.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d4ceztl

  2. I don’t have a favorite anime, but for a different reason: I don’t think it’s “fair” and compare shows that try to do different things, and I have trouble comparing them. How am I supposed to compare Aria the Animation, Seitokai no Ichizon, and ef – a tale of memories? They’re completely different.

  3. That’s why Roriconfan from MyAnimeList (sadley banned now) rated most anime anime so hard. I remember him saying the more you watch and the more you criticize the more you will realize what you like and which anime/movies are your personal favourites. I do not agree with every review from Roriconfan, but he made some valid points. It’s actually okay that you like Western cartoons more than anime from Japan right now, it’s just entertainment afterall (no matter how seriously people take it). My favourite list looks like this now ^^

    1.) Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
    2.) CodeGeass
    3.) GunBuster
    4.) PaniPoniDash!
    5.) StarDriver
    6.) Kaiji
    7.) Shamanic Princess
    8.) Ah! My Goddess Movie
    9.) .hack//SIGN
    10.) Kanon 2006

  4. Pingback: A 2 0 1 2 Overview | My Sword Is Unbelievably Dull

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s